Hundreds of people attended the Barry-Eaton District Board of Health meeting last week, and provided nearly five hours of arguments against the department's mask mandate.
Thursday's meeting might have gone on longer, but Adam Heikkila of Battle Creek brought it to a halt when he announced he was making a citizen’s arrest of Health Officer Colette Scrimger, and refused to leave the podium.
A sign on the front door of Leason Sharpe Hall states the room has a 175-person capacity. Even before the meeting started at 9:30 a.m., the room was filled and a line of people waiting to get inside stretched down the street and around the corner.
People waited patiently in the cold rainy conditions, holding umbrellas and listening to the meeting on their mobile devices. Several had young children with them. Some of them, when they finally got to the podium to speak, told the board they had waited outside for more than an hour and a half.
The first round of public comment, which started just after 9:30 a.m., went long enough for people to come in and speak on their lunch breaks. It did not end until after 2 p.m.
People told stories of their children’s struggles with masks when they were required last year. Several parents brought their children with them to speak about their experiences.
Students talked about being turned away at the door of their school, or being sent to the principal's office to await their parents, for refusing to wear their masks.
Many claimed masks are ineffective, or actively cause other health problems. Others accused Scrimger of manipulating or falsifying the district’s COVID data to justify the mandate. The vast majority of people who spoke Thursday demanded an end to the mask mandate – and many called for Scrimger’s resignation or termination.
Many of those who spoke, parents and children, became emotional as they spoke; some screamed and cried.
“I will tell you if I lose my daughter to suicide because of your mandate, and your malice and your negligence, there will be repercussions,” one woman, who did not give her name, wept as she shouted at the board. “You will not stand up here and kill my child!”
“Last year, my oldest would come home from school with a headache from wearing a mask, every day,” Maple Valley parent Scott Leslie said. “She cried the day she had to go to gym, because she knew what was coming and there was nothing she could do about it.
“I will not do that again. Nobody will make me do that again.”
Olivet parent Denver Rose referred to the Holocaust in her statement.
“I went to Poland, and I was in Auschwitz and I saw it, and you guys might say, ‘Oh my gosh, like it’s going to happen.’ It will, if this stuff keeps going on,” Rose said. “I will never be in a place like that; my children will never, and this is what I say to you: Over my dead body.”
“You cannot stand against the Lord most high,” Rose added. “He is greater than you, your mandates fall because he is greater.”
More than once, a person at the podium or someone in the audience led the group in prayer.
Another Maple Valley parent, Erin Stephens, asked for the health department to allow parents to sign a waiver allowing their children to be exempt from wearing masks.
“Sure, it may just be masks, but the fact that we don’t have a choice is tyranny,” Stephens said. “We can fight the tyranny from the government that we fought against in the (American) Revolution.”
Hastings Area Schools Superintendent Matt Goebel said he was speaking on behalf of himself and the Board of Education.
“I am here today to respectfully disagree with you today regarding the recent mandates regarding masks and quarantine options for educational institutions in Barry and Eaton counties,” Goebel said. “The Hastings Board of Education and I believe that giving parents the choice to mask their children is essential to the overall health of their individual child.”
“While I understand you come from a broader perspective of protecting health in two counties, I hope you can take into consideration the unfavorable effect this decision has on many of our students,” he added. “Furthermore, the announcement of this mandate in the middle of a semester, rather than at the very beginning of the school year, is just cruel to our students. It also negatively impacts our parents who are now forced to make different plans which upturn their lives.”
Delton Kellogg Schools Superintendent Kyle Corlett said he sent a letter to the board of health, stating he did not believe the mandates were necessary, based on the number of cases in area schools.
“My letter also said that a mask mandate would divide the community, as it has,” Corlett told The Banner. “We need a clear end goal in mind to base our decisions on and the mandate doesn't state when the mandate would end.
“As leaders in the community, we need to work together and communicate to help bring the community together.”
The Maple Valley Schools Board of Education unanimously adopted a resolution stating it did not believe the amount of COVID-19 infections warranted the mandates.
The health board did not take any action during its meeting last Thursday, besides its monthly business, such as paying the bills.
EDHD board chairman and Barry County Commissioner Ben Geiger said the agenda included an item for board members to voice their concerns and ask questions after the second round of public comment, but Heikkila’s intervention brought the meeting to an end before it could get to that point.
Barry County Commissioner and health board member Jon Smelker said he planned to use that time to ask Scrimger to rescind the order, and to ask for her resignation if she refused, but he did not get the chance.
Smelker said he had already had that conversation with Scrimger in private that morning, and she declined to do so.
Smelker said she informed him that, even if she stepped down, the mandates would remain in force.
Geiger said the Barry County Board of Commissioners has reached out to its legal counsel to ask if it has the legal authority to rescind Scrimger’s orders.
Health board member Dave Jackson, also a Barry County commissioner, spoke at the start of the meeting. He said he was grateful for the public participation, and asked audience members to be civil.
“We're glad you're here,” Jackson said. “It has been a long year and a half with this pandemic with mandates flying. ... I don't think many of you knew Colette prior to a week ago. But I have to assure you that your health department has a lot of troubling decisions that they've had to make. They've worked seven days a week for the last year and a half trying to do what's best for families.”
“Just be civil,” he added. “Because, in the end, we are still all friends or families or community. We live together, work together, our kids work and play with your kids.”
Even before Heikkila announced his citizen's arrest, the health board meeting had several tense moments. Hastings City Police officers, a Barry County Sheriff’s deputy and several posse members were posted at the entrance to Leason Sharpe Hall, and around the meeting area.
On several occasions, the officers took a few steps toward the audience, or asked people to calm down, when the meeting started to get out of hand.
After the first round of public comment, and a 20-minute recess, BEDHD official Anne Barna and epidemiologist Taylor Olsabeck gave a presentation on the current state of the pandemic.
Their report occasional laughter from the audience as the employees talked about the number of cases, and several people called out questions.
At one point, Geiger, who sat at the front of the audience area to see the slideshow presentation, stood up.
“We do have some questions from the audience and I will be receptive to entertaining [them],” Geiger said. “But this is my only rule, and this is a ground rule, treat these staff members with a little grace, cut them a little slack.”
“No,” a woman called out from the audience, as several people started speaking at once.
“When are you going to give our kids a break?” one man shouted at Geiger and got out of his seat.
Police and posse members took a few steps forward until the man sat down.
“No, listen to me, I’m a politician ...” Geiger started to say but was shouted down.
“If you have questions I’m going to let you ask, just don’t yell at them,” he said.
But audience members continued to shout at Geiger.
“All right, well, we can’t have this,” Geiger said, then he sat back down and called for the presentation to continue.
After the presentation was over, Geiger tried to take questions from the audience where answers could be offered, but eventually he stopped that attempt as unruly responses continued to erupt from the audience.
The next health board meeting is scheduled for 9:30 a.m. Oct. 28. A location has not been announced.
Geiger said the board had not yet decided whether it would call a special meeting before then.
As of Tuesday, BEDHD reported 140 active cases of COVID-19 in Barry County, down from 175 the week before. Two additional deaths were reported, for a total of 75 since the pandemic began in March 2020.