Maple Valley Schools canceled classes for the rest of the week on Tuesday night, to give families time to prepare for the new mask requirements, and because of a number of COVID-19 positive tests and exposures in the district.
The board met for seven hours between Monday and Tuesday night to hear public comment on the Barry-Eaton District Health Department’s new mandates and discuss the district’s response.
The health department issued two orders last Friday, requiring public school students to wear masks and quarantine if they are close contacts, starting Wednesday.
Hundreds of parents, community members and students attended the board meetings of Maple Valley, Hastings Area Schools, Delton Kellogg Schools and Caledonia Community Schools to speak out on the new orders.
Many parents demanded their school boards defy the mask mandate, and said they would not allow their children to wear a mask at school.
Several parents said they would pull their children out of the school district if masks are required.
Few people spoke in support of the mandates.
“I’m telling you right now, I will not mask my kids, I will not quarantine them,” Sara Brumm told the Maple Valley Board of Education Monday night. “… These are our God-given rights and you will not take that away. Our family is prepared to un-enroll our children. We will not put them through this again.”
Maple Valley Superintendent Katherine Bertolini outlined a number of reasons behind the decision to cancel school, in an update on the district’s website.
“We had minimal time to adjust to the masking and quarantine emergency orders that went into effect today, which was creating confusion, frustration and challenges for many of our families,” Bertolini said.
“Due to the publicly shared intention to protest and challenge the orders, many parents were notifying us that they would not bring their children to school to witness that discord,” she added.
The district also had several positive COVID tests and exposures among staff, which, given the shortage of substitute teachers, would have created a loss of teacher coverage in some classes. Fuller Street Elementary had 31 reported instances of COVID-19 close contacts among staff and students.
The combination of COVID quarantines, and parents who were planning to keep their kids home on Wednesday, may have led to the district exceeding the 25 percent limit for absences for the state to count the day as part of the school year, Bertolini explained.
“Ironically,” she added Wednesday, “the power was out in Fuller this morning, so that would have resulted in closure there as well.”
The closure Wednesday and Thursday will take two of the districts six days allowed by the state for emergencies such snow days and power outages.
Friday, which was already scheduled as a professional development day for staff only, will proceed as planned.
Board trustee Justin Keiffer told parents they could use the extra days to obtain doctors notes stating their children have a medical exemption to the mask order, and speak out at the Board of Health meeting Thursday norming.
The school board also unanimously passed a resolution stating the school will follow lawful mandates, and allowable exceptions, but the board does not believe the current COVID-19 caseload warrants the Barry-Eaton District Health Department’s latest mandates.
The resolution also asked for a broader definition of mask exemptions, and BEDHD’s assistance with tracking tracing positive cases and close contacts of
COVID-19.
Local parent and coach Mike Walker, a strident critic of the new orders, told the board he was happy with their decision, and he felt it was a step in the right direction.
“Don’t take this as a threat by any way,” Walker said. “But you’ve seen how we will come out of the woodwork. We’ve behaved. I don’t want anybody to misbehave. I don’t want any kid to miss school, but please remember that this issue is this important, and I don’t want to see this community destroyed over it. But this is our choice.”
During a Hastings Board of Education meeting Monday, Superintendent Matt Goebel read a letter to the community explaining the school’s response.
“It is imperative that you understand that these orders are mandated by the health department, and do not express my personal views nor that of the Hastings Board of Education,” Goebel said.
“I would prefer that the health department give the local school districts the options and choice that they did at the beginning of the school year,” he told
The Banner after the meeting.
“I am asking you, and the board, to stand up and not comply with these mandates,” Christine Becker said during public comment. “This isn't OK. This is going to be a domino effect. The more you give in, the more they're going to keep doing it. Enough is enough.”
Later, trustee Dan Patton told the crowd “you can come to school board meetings and have some impact, but it’s pretty limited. Our hands are tied as much as anybody.”
Instead, he encouraged people to contact their elected officials and attend community meetings.
Goebel said board members reached out to the Barry County Board of Commissioners, and he contacted State Representative Julie Calley.
He also relayed the community’s response to BEDHD Health Officer Colette Scrimger, during a meeting between area school officials and the health department Wednesday morning.
“I think this particular mandate has made a tremendous disruption,” Goebel said. “I think it goes all the way down to just scheduling. … [We’re] in the midst of this semester. And now we have some kids that have been doing in-person learning for a period of time and want to go virtual, and then they may want to come back. I believe that kids thrive in more of a routine and structure environment.”
More than 75 people attended the Delton Kellogg Board of Education meeting on Monday to protest the mask mandate, and around 20 spoke during public comment.
Some threatened to take their children out of the Delton school district if the mandate stays.
“If we don’t take a stand our children will be in another school,” one person said. “Mandates are not a law, why are we treating it like it is?” another man asked. “You are going to lose so many students.”
Superintendent Kyle Corlett said he and the board have no choice, they have to follow the law. He said with just four cases of COVID and few, if any, symptoms, he didn’t think the mask mandate was needed at this time.
“I will advocate for no masks,” Corlett said.
He wrote a letter to the Barry-Eaton District Health Department, arguing against the mask mandate, and spoke at the Barry County Board of Commissioners meeting on Tuesday to do the same.
Thornapple Kellogg Schools did not meet this week, but interim superintendent Craig McCarthy said the district will follow the mandates.
“The health department is charged with protecting the health of the citizens in both Barry and Eaton Counties and they have to make difficult decisions,”
McCarthy told The Banner. “The district is compelled by law, and board policy, to adhere to those decisions. While the decision to issue a mask mandate has created challenges for everyone, we are doing our best to work through them. I would ask for patience on behalf of the community and reiterate that we must comply with this mandate.”
Lakewood Public Schools Superintendent Steven Skalka released a statement on Facebook regarding BEDHD’s new orders on Sunday.
“Put simply, during the duration of the orders, we are returning to last school year’s rules and expectations for isolation of positive individuals, quarantining of close contacts, and everyone wearing a mask while inside the school building,” Skalka wrote.
He also addressed the question many parents have: ‘why doesn’t the school district ignore the orders?’
Skalka said the board of education and administration have consistently held the position of following all federal, state and local orders.
He added “the question of whether a ‘mask mandate’ is legal has already been decided.”
He cited a case in the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, which upheld the legal basis for mask mandates in Michigan.
In southeast Kent County at Caledonia Community Schools, students in kindergarten through sixth grade are under a Kent County Health Department mask mandate. Nearly 100 people turned out for a school board meeting Monday night at the Duncan Lake Middle School performing arts center, mostly to protest the mask mandate and call on the board to defy the health department's order.
School board member Tim Morris spoke out during the meeting in favor of leaving the decision on masking to parents.
“There is no lesser vulnerable COVID-19 demographic than the ages found in [grades] K-through-6. The mandate decision is completely void of common sense,” said Morris, who has served on the school board since 2012. “I'm trying to find the basis for this emergency. The masking of our parents' children is creating many health issues, while making existing health issues worse.
“I personally have heard from parents whose children are now experiencing new [physical] health and mental health-related issues, directly tied to the
effects of masking. I believe the vast majority of the community would support a common sense approach, alternatives to the mandate that was handed to us.
“This is not an easy task. The board members up here, every one of us, cares about the community and kids. It's not an easy task. I feel that the community would support us in this matter. I am just not finding this as a solution that's working,” Morris added.
One parent, Betsy Oppel, wore a white hazmat suit as she sought to illustrate her point about what she sees is the futility of masking students.
“If our children are truly in imminent danger, why aren't they wearing hazmat suits?” Oppel asked. “Why are kids even allowed in school? Do you really feel like a cloth mask is going to protect our children? I'm not buying this.”
“I ask, why are you doing this? My only answer is funding. So let's be honest with ourselves. Our schools have sold their children out for funding. Our children are not people anymore. They're strictly dollar signs and data.”