A 48-year-old Hastings man was arrested in the early hours of Aug. 5, after a high-speed chase and a seven-hour armed standoff with police at a gas station in Woodland.
Timothy Maloy Riddle was being sought as a suspect in a recent Barry County break-in, police said.
Hastings City Police spotted Riddle’s matte black Chevy HHR at the Marathon gas station on M-43 in Hastings at 6:48 p.m. Aug. 4. After Riddle left the station and turned north onto M-43, an officer stopped him. He detailed his interaction with Riddle in a written report.
The officer told Riddle he was not under arrest, but that Barry County Sheriff’s deputies wanted to talk to him. He asked Riddle to step out of the car and wait for the deputies.
Riddle appeared agitated at first, but he seemed to cool down after the officer explained the situation to him.
He shut off the car and pulled out the key – but would not step out of the vehicle.
He started talking about his ex-girlfriend, a 40-year-old Hastings woman, and insisted to the officer that he did not go near her.
“I did not do nothing to her, man,” Riddle said.
The officer told him he was not being pulled over because of his ex-girlfriend, but Riddle kept talking about her and grew more agitated.
The officer told him to step out of the vehicle or hand over the key. Riddle held the key out the window, as if to hand it over, but pulled it back inside.
“I’m just going to book it,” he said, and started the ignition.
Twice the officer told Riddle not to leave.
“I am,” Riddle said, and he drove off at a high rate of speed.
The officer took off after Riddle, driving north on M-43. Other officers from the city police and sheriff’s office soon joined the pursuit.
According to the report, Riddle drove at more than 115 mph in an attempt to elude the police. More than once, he pointed a shotgun at the Hastings City Police cruiser behind him, which led the officer to back off and increase the distance between them.
The chase ended at the parking lot of the Mobil gas station on M-43, east of Woodland. Details of what occurred there will not be released until after Michigan State Police Troopers finish their investigation of the standoff.
Troopers did say that when Riddle got out of his vehicle, wielding a stolen shotgun, a sheriff's deputy fired shots. No one was hit.
As Riddle went inside the gas station and barricaded himself, at least one customer was able to escape the building. Two employees inside the store hid from Riddle and were later able to get outside. They were not harmed, police said.
At some point, however, shots were fired inside the building.
The Michigan State Police Emergency Support Team soon arrived at the scene and started negotiating with Riddle. At 1:30 a.m., after nearly seven hours of standoff and negotiations, he surrendered.
He was taken to Spectrum Health Pennock for evaluation and then to jail. He sustained minor injuries, although no police or bystanders reported any injuries.
Riddle was charged with three felonies later that day. These include felonious assault, which carries a maximum sentence of four years in prison, fleeing and eluding a police officer, which carries a maximum of two years; and resisting and obstructing a police officer, which carries a maximum of two years in prison.
Barry County Prosecutor Julie Nakfoor Pratt said her office expects to file additional charges on behalf of multiple police agencies.
State troopers said the investigation is continuing, and witnesses are being sought. They are being asked to contact the state police Wayland Post at 269-792-2213.
The court record shows that Riddle has spent most of his life behind bars.
He was 15 when he was convicted in 1988 of breaking and entering and felony murder.
According to a Detroit Free Press article from the time, Riddle broke into the home of 80-year-old Renate Henie and crushed her skull with a beer bottle. Her body was found two weeks later.
Riddle was sentenced to prison for life. But he was released on parole in November 2019, after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life sentences for juveniles are unconstitutional.
The Hastings City Police said they have had contact with Riddle in 23 separate incidents since August 2020. In most of those incidents, Riddle was either a suspect or was arrested.
In November 2020 police interviewed Riddle after a Hastings Secretary of State employee reported a rude encounter with him at her office.
As he was leaving, the woman told police she heard Riddle say, “I’m going to burn this place down.”
Riddle admitted to officers that he might have said that, and told them he has a tendency to get angry and say things he doesn't mean. He later pleaded guilty to disturbing the peace.
Riddle called police at 1:47 a.m. March 17, to report a man throwing things at a residence in Hastings. But when police arrived, a woman told them Riddle had slammed a door on her hand, causing her to fall the to the ground and scrape her knee. Riddle told police he was “amped up” after drinking two espressos at the hospital.
Police requested a warrant for his arrest in that case, but it was denied.
On March 27, Riddle’s ex-girlfriend said he attacked her while they were driving in a vehicle in Hastings. The woman said he accused her of sleeping with her adopted nephew, and he almost hit the nephew with the car.
She said he threatened to kill her, would not let her out of the car and hit her on the hand. Officers saw her hand was swollen.
The woman also said Riddle talked about committing “suicide by cop.”
Riddle told police he did not hit the woman, and accused her of hitting him.
When asked about his comment about wanting to commit “suicide by cop,” Riddle told the officers that, “while he often feels he should have remained in prison and doesn’t want to be alive, he would never put that on another person’s conscience.”
When officers told Riddle a warrant might be issued for his arrest in the March 27 incident, he said he would willing turn himself in “as he’s tired of living this lifestyle,” an officer wrote in his report.
Riddle was charged with domestic violence, but it was dismissed.
He was then arrested on May 24 for stealing a credit card in a store in Hastings on Jan. 26, 2021.
He was convicted of larceny in a building for that offense in July and sentenced by Barry County Judge Michael Schipper to serve 59 days in jail, with credit for 59 days served; ordered to pay $398 in fines and costs; and placed on probation for 24 months.
Riddle also was ordered to participate in the Office of Community Corrections' Cognitive Behavior Therapy program. A second charge of illegal use of a financial transaction device was dismissed at the time of his sentencing.
He was released after his sentencing, on July 21.
Just hours after his release, Riddle was accused of assaulting his ex-girlfriend in Hastings. An employee of a West State Street business reported hearing two people fighting outside a camper and saw a man throwing punches before running away.
Riddle’s ex-girlfriend said he hit her in the face. She told the officers she was afraid he would come back and “he needs to be in jail.”
He was arrested in Nashville later that night.
Riddle was charged with domestic violence, although he ultimately pleaded guilty to disturbing the peace on Aug. 3. The next day, Riddle was already a suspect in a breaking and entering case, and he led police on the chase that ended at the Mobil gas station in Woodland.
He will appear before Judge Schipper for a probable cause conference at 10 a.m. Aug. 25. It’s a place Riddle has been before; he was sentenced on July 21 by Schipper for the credit card theft, and pleaded guilty on Aug. 3 in that courtroom to disturbing the peace.
But since Riddle hasn't pleaded guilty to any recent major or violent crime in Barry County, Schipper said his offenses didn’t rise above the level of probation.
Although the Hastings City Police requested domestic violence charges on more than one occasion, that information never crossed Schipper’s desk.
“I never hear about the cases that are being investigated, all I see is when they come into court,” Schipper said. “… There was no domestic violence that he pled to, or that I have any record of.”
The Barry County Prosecutor’s Office declined to comment on Riddle’s case, outside of the initial press release sent out last week about the standoff with police in Woodland.
The judge did speak to the challenge of reintegrating someone into society after they have been in prison for most of their life.
“When you take a kid at 15, 16 years old and you throw him in prison for 30 years, they basically are raised in prison,” Schipper said. “I don’t know how they get out and have any clue of how to live in society.”
“That has to be so hard,” Schipper added, “unless you’ve got such a good family support system that can just take you in and basically raise you and kind of teach you for a few years. I don’t know how you do that.”
Schipper also praised law enforcement’s handling of the standoff with Riddle.
“The situation with Mr. Riddle was a perfect example of how amazing law enforcement in Barry County is,” he said. “That situation very easily could’ve ended in numerous people hurt and, instead, it ended up in absolutely no one hurt.
“Law enforcement in Barry County does an amazing job and are incredibly patient.”