Middleville Village President Amanda Fisk issued a public apology Tuesday night regarding a social media post she made Feb. 17, responding to the death of conservative radio talk show host Rush Limbaugh.
However, some village residents aren’t buying the apology, questioning Fisk’s sincerity, and one resident says she will start a campaign to recall Fisk from office.
Detractors and supporters of Fisk spoke out for more than two hours during the public comment portion of Tuesday’s village council meeting, which was held virtually. At one point, 346 participants were on the Zoom call, Village Manager Patricia Rayl said.
“I made an insensitive comment. I have zero [excuse],” Fisk said during the council comment period shortly before the meeting adjourned.
“I’m not going to defend it, I’m not going to tell you that I’ll never have knee-jerk reaction again,” Fisk said. “I’m not going to say that it wasn’t inappropriate and insensitive, not for a second. I’m not going to argue that I did something that was right, I wouldn’t dream of it. I hear the opinions and thoughts on both sides.
“I agree, it was a very stupid mistake, no question. I apologize for the insensitivity of the statement, and moving forward, I’d like my personal record as a member of this council to stand for itself as well. I have been bipartisan in everything I’ve ever done on this council ... I don’t even know the political affiliations of anyone I’m looking at on this call right now. It doesn’t matter to our jobs. It’s never been an issue, to my knowledge, for any of us. We do all that work bipartisan, and we run for our seats nonpartisan. I hope to continue to do that work moving forward – just the same as I have for the last two years.”
Fisk was appointed by her council colleagues Jan. 12 to fill the seat left vacant by the death of longtime Village President Charlie Pullen. Pullen died Nov. 20, 2020, of complications from COVID-19, a little more than two weeks after he had run unopposed for re-election to the office he’d held for 11 years.
Theresa Dickerson, a village resident, said she had read an online apology from Fisk over her comments and found it “lacking.”
“It was more or less a non-apology. It struck me as ‘sorry, not sorry,’” Dickerson said. “When you are in a position of a president of any village or town, you are in the public eye. People are watching and listening, I was shocked and appalled by what she posted on Rush Limbaugh. I was aggravated by the non-apology … I am asking the council to encourage her to resign.”
Keara Hilton, who has lived in Middleville for 17 years and who started a change.org petition calling for Fisk’s ouster, said in a text message to the Banner Tuesday night that she had emailed Barry County Clerk Pamela Palmer to ask about a recall petition against Fisk, and that Palmer said she would send Hilton a blank petition because the clerk’s office is currently closed after an employee tested positive for COVID-19.
“Over Amanda's time as village president, she has repeatedly and openly insulted a large majority of the people that she was appointed to represent, and unapologetically so,” Hilton said during the public comment period. “I waited patiently for our [council] to take notice, as Amanda's hateful, vulgar and distasteful statements were not muted in the least, nor a secret to anyone that performed a simple search of her name on any social media outlet. Her social media outlets, which she states were ‘private,’ may have been her personal pages but they were most definitely not private.
“Her distaste for an entire political party was very evident and publicly accessible, creating a feeling of insecurity amongst many residents here, regarding Amanda's capacity to truly represent us as a whole.”
As of Wednesday afternoon, nearly 2,900 people had signed Hilton’s petition. It’s not known how many of the signatures were from village residents.
Hilton questioned the legality of Fisk’s appointment at the Jan. 12 meeting because it was done virtually and not during an in-person meeting, which she said violates the Michigan Open Meetings Act.
“What exactly were the qualifications for the village president position, and what vetting process was in place to ensure appropriate representation for our taxpaying community members? I have searched the village webpage and was able to find the qualifications for all positions except this one, so I am hopeful that you can clarify this for me. I cannot help but wonder how our village council could have overlooked the hateful remarks that Amanda has made against an entire population of our residents,” she said.
Hilton also took issue with a change the village made in its meeting notice. The initial public meeting notice that was on the village website last week said every email or letter sent to the village regarding Fisk would be read aloud during Tuesday’s meeting. However, that notice was changed Monday at the recommendation of attorney Mark Nettleton, Village Clerk Glorimar Ayala said in a telephone interview Wednesday morning.
“We made that change when we started getting flooded with emails,” Rayl said in a telephone interview Wednesday morning.
Rayl said her office received 117 emails regarding Fisk – 31 from village residents. Among village residents, 18 were critical of Fisk while 13 were supportive. Among emails from outside the village, 67 were critical of Fisk and 13 were supportive. Six other emails, which did not identify a community of origin, would not have been read into the record because they contained threatening or foul language, Rayl said.
“There was no way, as a practical matter, that we could have read all 117 letters,” she said.
All the emails will be posted in the document section of the village website, Rayl said.
The controversy over Fisk’s comments has made its way into West Michigan media and even onto a national website, the conservative news site Breitbart.
Alan Buckowing, a village resident who classifies himself as an independent voter, said while he seldom agreed with Limbaugh’s views, he called Fisk’s Facebook post “inappropriate.”
“These are not the words or actions befitting anyone on the council, let alone the president,” Buckowing said. “Her lack of empathy demonstrates a stark divide in the values that she is supposed to represent. Empathy is a trait paramount to effective leadership. These are certainly not qualities or attitudes that reflect what our community believes.”
“This is not about your views, rather this is about your communication, causing division and polarization in our community,” resident Cori Curtis said. “It shows a lack of respect and a failure to listen to viewpoints that are different than your own. It demonstrates that you view people who think differently are beneath you and worthy of a painful death, such as the one Rush Limbaugh experienced. Shame on you.”
Kim Smith, a village resident and business owner, raised concern with the direction of the village under Fisk’s leadership.
“I see Amanda pushing for marijuana dispensaries in our community. I don’t think that’s a good thing for the children and teens in Middleville to make it so easily accessible,” Smith said. “I think it’s that type of liberal agenda that we moved to Middleville to get away from, and it’s why we chose to raise our family here and why I’ve chosen to run my business here for the last 20 years.”
Others defended Fisk, some using words like “lynch mob” and “witch hunt” to describe calls for her ouster.
“I support free speech, and I support Amanda Fisk’s right to share whatever she chooses on her private Facebook page,” resident Jennifer Meyer said. “Her comment pales in comparison to the hate speech that Rush Limbaugh repeatedly shared on [commercial] radio … I find this fabricated outrage and calls for her resignation to be ridiculous. I frankly think this whole issue has been blown out of proportion. I think it’s shameful.”
Danielle Hoskins, a lifelong Middleville resident, called the reaction against Fisk “bullying.”
“It’s been heartbreaking to see the venom spit at her, to see the verbal attacks on her family, wishing her children harm, implying that violence or ruin will be coming to her, blatantly threatening her physical safety and wishing general ill upon her family,” Hoskins said. “We’re talking about a lifelong resident of this small town, a single mother of two, a volunteer in the community, a hardworking, contributing citizen – not some boogeyman living on Capitol Hill.”
“If Amanda would have been at the scene of the insurrection on Jan. 6, I would be the first to call for her resignation,” Tamara Purdum said. “I do not feel in any way she has tarnished our community. I feel those that took it to the news have tarnished our community … this should have been handled by the people who give of their time and run for positions on the board, and not pressured by armchair quarterbacks.”
Nicholas Janose, a classmate of Fisk’s at Thornapple Kellogg High School, defended Fisk’s right to free speech, noting that her Facebook post was not on a village account.
“Has she committed a crime? Is there a hearing? Is she going to be detained or arrested?” Janose, a military veteran, asked. “This is a witch hunt, and it’s ridiculous. I didn’t sign up to defend this kind of stuff.”
While some residents called for the council to vote to remove Fisk from office, Nettleton said under state law, the council cannot take that action.
“The council is without authority, under Michigan law, to remove or force a council member to resign,” Nettleton said. “The only avenues that exist under state law include a recall effort by petition, and there are specific rules governing that process. There are narrow circumstances for removal of an elected official by the governor, and those circumstances and that power is very rarely used.”
Fisk was elected to the council in 2018. She has been the village’s representative on the Thornapple Area Parks and Recreation Commission. She announced her candidacy for Barry County clerk as a Democrat last year but later withdrew her candidacy.
The strongest comments among Fisk’s colleagues came from Trustee Mike Cramer.
“I, myself as a resident, feel unrepresented,” Cramer said. “That’s not something that anyone should feel. We are the moral standard for this community. We need to represent that in this community. These comments don’t represent the views of this board. They don’t represent most of the views of the citizens of this village.”
Cramer brought up an earlier social media post by Fisk criticizing a Caledonia business, OSKAR Scots, last summer, which had violated state coronavirus-related restrictions, and had hoped that she had learned her lesson from the experience.
“I would have brought these things up had we deliberated in a public forum. We did not. That did not happen in our meeting to appoint Ms. Fisk to her position,” Cramer said. “That should be looked into. I believe there was an oversight, I believe there was wrongdoing, and it should be investigated.”
Trustee Kevin Smith called for a “calculated outcome delivered with calm, dignified resolve.”
“Let’s start here, tonight, by agreeing that ‘scorched earth’ commentary is no longer tolerated; that we as Americans can have civilized discourse with one another, publicly or privately, without compromising the very fabric of the mechanisms which led us to become the greatest nation on Earth,” Smith said. “Most importantly, our actions and words matter, and to disregard the consequences of those actions or words as a community leader, servant or citizen should – and will – be weighed and measured.”
Smith and Cramer both sought appointment to the open president’s seat, which was awarded to Fisk.
Trustee Mike Lytle said he was “disappointed” by Fisk’s post, but also said he was troubled with some of the views expressed by her opponents.
“We got some emails, I couldn’t believe, that were threatening the whole board, and they don’t even know us,” Lytle said. “Tom DeVries and Kevin Smith just got on [the council]. The whole board was [being labeled as] sinners. I can’t believe that. There was foul language and veiled threats. That’s not any better than what she did. These people are doing what she did. They’re trying to bully us.”
“If she resigns, that’s up to her. I’m not going to force her out,” Lytle added. “She made a mistake, in my opinion.”
President Pro Tempore Sherry Ronning said she was “upset” and “disturbed” by the events of the past week.
“We came together as a council. We decided who we felt was our best candidate, but I do believe that there’s a code of ethics that somebody needs to march by,” Ronning said. “I cannot live through another repeat of this. There’s a lot that’s been said tonight, there’s a lot I need to digest. This is unnecessary drama that none of us had to have gone through.”