It is a longtime practice of the Barry County commissioners not to respond to citizens when they speak during the public comment portion of board meetings.
As Chairman Ben Geiger has explained in the past, county commissioners are allowed plenty of time to speak during their sessions - so commissioners do not infringe upon the time allotted for public comment.
But, in recent weeks, this protocol has become a recurring sore point for residents who make specific demands during public comment time and expect a direct response.
Several have complained about it.
“I would have better luck talking to a wall,” Aaron Gross of Hastings told the board Tuesday, “because at least I know how to fix a wall.”
This time, however, commissioners didn’t have to respond directly to some of the comment from citizens.
Others in the audience took care of it for them.
The issue that prompted passionate responses was the American Rescue Plan Act.
Some residents urged the board not to accept ARPA funds.
“If we were a community of upstanding people, we’d send that money back,” Charles Hertzler of Hastings said. “… That’s our taxpayer money. I think we need to send it back and tell them to stick it.”
In the meantime, Hertzler suggested, commissioners should schedule a night meeting, much like they did when a jail proposal was being considered, to allow people to ask questions.
A special panel of sector experts, led by Barry Community Foundation President and CEO Bonnie Gettys, reviewed all project applications and, weighing them against the restrictions and requirements set by the federal government, scored each one.
The public needs to know how that scoring was done on the list of projects now under consideration after applications were submitted, Hertzler said.
Hertzler expressed the certainty that any spending on proposed projects in the county would help about 10 percent of the county and cause more division.
“We will survive,” he said. “I know things are tight. Taking this blood money will only make things worse.”
After Hertzler was done, Michelle Peltier of Hastings stood up and spoke.
“I appreciate that you’re all working on ARPA projects,” Peltier told commissioners. “And that you’ve identified things that will improve infrastructures for the future.
“It was good to see last week the projects that were listed – and that you’re investigating it – and you’re going to help the townships identify more.”
“This money has already been dispersed from the federal government,” she added. “To turn it back would be cutting off our nose to spite our face.”
“And I appreciate that you’re looking at projects; any improvement in this county is improvement for everyone,” Peltier said to Hertzler’s assertion. “There should not be resentment if one township, or one city, or one municipality, does benefit from it. We will all benefit from the improvements in Barry County.”
But Eldon Shellenbarger of Hastings said he had a problem with ARPA money, particularly with regard to spending it for a $2.4 million build-out of one 800 MHz communications tower site to increase load capacity, coverage and increased interoperability for a safer communications platform.
This project, which had been ranked third by the county’s special panel, was requested by Barry County Central Dispatch/911 Director Stephanie Lehman and Emergency Management Coordinator Jim Yarger.
“Why wasn’t these towers put in the proper place to begin with?” Shellenbarger asked the board. “There were issues with 800 to begin with; went with 700; now going back to 800.”
Shellenbarger said, if the state police weren’t having an issue with the system, why would the county be having trouble with it. The project would be “wasting money on radio towers,” he said. “Aren’t there towers we can rent that would work a whole lot better than building a new tower system?
The responses to his comments were immediate and passionate.
Yarger of Irving Township and the fire chief in Freeport, who has worked in fire service for 42 years, approached the podium and told commissioners, his voice shaking, “If you have questions about the radio system, come to those of us who use it – not the people who’ve never been on the radio, not the ones who have never had to put their lives on the line and use the radio system.”
Yarger noted that the county’s migration from 800 to 700 MHz had nothing to do with the frequency not working, it had to do with the Federal Communications system selling the 800 spectrum they were on.
“As far as towers go, and renting and where it should be, there’s a lot of things that go into that,” Yarger added. “We did get left out in the early stages of the 800 MHz digital system, which is what the state is.
“We have VHF system the county fire runs on. We have a lot of interference problems with that. There’s days – not very many yet, but they keep getting worse – we have days we can’t get out on VHF when the static is so bad and, when somebody’s life is on the line, we’d like to get back to dispatcher or the command.”
“If you have questions about the radio system, please come to those who know,” he emphasized.
Then Stephanie Lehman of Yankee Springs Township spoke up.
“I would love to be able to stand up here and educate everybody on the one 800 MHz infrastructure tower that we currently have sitting near the intersection of M-79 and Swift Road in Barry County, but the fact of the matter is I was not a decision-maker for 911, I was in high school … At that time, the state, the Michigan Public Safety Communications System, was responsible for the infrastructure build-out. So, Barry County was fortunate enough to receive one tower.
“The state is no longer building infrastructure. The number of first responders that we have utilizing the system has quadrupled since about 1998. The system has a limited amount of capability.
“And, at this time, our system is overloaded. As a local unit of government, a municipality, we don’t have a choice but to try to meet and accommodate the need in today’s public safety market, and, unfortunately, we just are not quite there.
“Historically, 911, through our millage, has been able to provide that infrastructure. Unfortunately, the cost of this infrastructure does not allow us to do that.”
As she addressed the commissioners, Lehman enunciated the following words with greater emphasis: “The cost of one site exceeds our annual budget for one year.
“So, we presently have one tower. All of the studies show that we probably need to have between six or seven, depending on how those towers are engineered. And I can share in the sentiment that Mr. Yarger shared with you earlier.
“If you only have one chance, you’re in a basement or you’re in a house that’s collapsing because you’re fighting a fire, or you’re a law enforcement officer fighting with someone for their life, or you’re EMS fighting with a patient for their life … and you have one opportunity to get out, and that system is overloaded and you miss your opportunity – and we at 911 are not able to meet the needs of our first responders.
“It’s pretty hard to put a dollar amount on what that means to all of us.”
Lehman concluded that the joint application for ARPA funding involves 911 and emergency management in Barry County. They have letters of support from every law enforcement agency in the county, along with others.
A final claim, made by Hertzler, was that the city of Hastings is on the verge of bankruptcy and “about to be taken over by the state.” That statement was quietly refuted by a county commissioner – but only after the meeting had ended.
“Don’t believe a word he says,” one commissioner remarked as he walked out of the room.
The Banner covered the Hastings City Council meeting Monday and a full report of that meeting is in this edition. No bankruptcy is imminent; nor was any possibility of a state takeover discussed.
Hertzler did express his appreciation to commissioners for scheduling a night meeting to discuss ARPA projects.
That meeting is being scheduled for 7 p.m. Tuesday, Nov. 30. A site has yet to be determined.
Geiger said it wouldn’t surprise him if as many as 300 audience members attend.
In other action, commissioners:
• Adopted a resolution to approve a new master agreement between the Michigan Department of Transportation and Barry County Board of Commissioners and authorized Transit Director William Voigt to sign it.
• Authorized fiscal year 2022 adult specialty court grants for the Swift and Sure prison diversion program for high-risk offenders, sobriety court, Secure Continuous Remote Alcohol Monitoring (SCRAM) and Adult Drug Court.
• Approved proposed health plans for county employees for 2022.
• Approved the use of $5,065 in animal shelter donation funds to purchase a pre-made barn to house equipment.
•Approved hiring a new full-time detective for the sheriff’s department.